Clean the Lint Filterby Work Shouldn't Suck

Month 5 of 8

Repair

What happens when things go sideways, and how you come back.

The move

The three restorative questions

The moment it is for

You feel slightly different with someone and can trace it to a specific moment that was never addressed.

What it takes

One 90-minute session. A minute or two a day. Ten minutes a week.

Start here · about 5 minutes

Guess, then read

This month's lens comes from restorative justice and Indigenous circle practice.

Two guesses before you read anything. Guessing first, even wrong, makes the reading stick. (It is also slightly annoying. Sorry.)

About “sorry if anyone was offended”

A meeting goes badly. Someone gets talked over, or cut out of a decision, or corrected in front of a client. Later there is an apology. “Sorry about earlier.” “No worries.” Everyone gets back to work.

Three weeks on, something is still slightly off between them. (The whole team can feel it. Only two people could tell you the date it started.)

The apology was a transaction: issued, received, filed. The part that does the repairing never happened. The person affected never said what it cost, and the other person never had to understand it.

Restorative justice practitioners, building on Indigenous circle practice, ask three questions in a fixed order.

Three questions, in this order

  1. 1What happened?From my side. Observable. No motives.
  2. 2What was the impact?What it cost: trust, status, confidence, belonging.
  3. 3What would make it right?Right enough to keep working together.

Blame and who was right are missing from that list on purpose.

Repair is rarer than a daily event, so this month’s rep is lighter. Once a day, notice one piece of unfinished business and run the three questions on it in your head. Once this month, do it out loud.

Before the live session · one required piece

Howard Zehr's Restorative Justice Threes (restorativejustice.org)

Short. Zehr’s own summary of the framework.

Next: Try it here

On your own · about 12 minutes

Try it here

Three short practice rounds load here. If you are logged in to Squarespace and see only this line, view the page logged out.

Next: Practice together

The live session · 90 minutes

Practice together

One session at the start of the month. Everyone tries the move once, with real people.

Run of show
0:00–0:10Check-in. On a scale of 1 to 10, how comfortable are you with apologizing? Say the number.
0:10–0:30Core concept. The difference between an apology and repair. What the research says about what works.
0:30–0:55Circle practice. A simplified restorative circle using a real past anonymized team situation. Three questions: what happened, what was the impact, and what would repair look like?
0:55–1:15Debrief. What surprised you? What felt true in the circle that does not usually get said?
1:15–1:25Set the daily rep and meeting hook.
1:25–1:30Close.

The reflection rep works fully alone. For the circle practice, you cannot run a solo circle, so instead write the three questions about one real rupture and, if the other person is willing, ask them for a short conversation using the Repair Prep Sheet.

What to have in the room

This month’s worksheet (PDF)
Handouts and frameworks
Session handoutTHE THREE RESTORATIVE QUESTIONS (Howard Zehr)

Most organizational repair asks: what rule was broken and what is the consequence?
Restorative practice asks three different questions:

  • What happened and who was affected? What occurred, and what did it cost in trust, relationship, confidence, belonging. Blame can wait.
  • What does the affected person need? What should happen to the person who caused harm comes later, if it comes at all.
  • What would make this right? What repair would restore the relationship? The standard consequence may have nothing to do with it.

These questions shift the conversation from retributive to relational. The goal is repair.

Session handoutCIRCLE PRACTICE FORMAT

A structure for conversations that need more space than a normal meeting provides.

Setup: Arrange seating so everyone faces each other. Choose a talking piece, any small object that passes around the circle. Only the person holding it speaks.

Open: Name the purpose. “We are here to…”

Opening round: Each person answers one question in turn, uninterrupted. No cross-talk.

Core rounds: The talking piece passes around for each question or topic.

Closing round: Each person completes a sentence such as “I am leaving with…”

What the structure does: slows the conversation down, ensures every voice is heard, and prevents the loudest person from setting the agenda.

Three practice scenarios

Scenario 1
A team member made a decision affecting others without consulting them. Two months later, colleagues are still carrying it. Using the three questions: who was affected? What did it cost? What would repair look like: something specific that restores trust, beyond an apology?

Scenario 2
Your team has come through a difficult period where trust eroded. Run a short circle. Opening question: what have you been carrying since that period that you have not said? Then: what do you need from this team going forward?

Scenario 3
You need to repair something with a specific person. A small rupture that has been lingering between you. Using the prep sheet: what happened? What do you think it cost them? What do you need to acknowledge? What are you asking for going forward?

Next: Keep it going

All month · a minute or two a day

Keep it going

Decide now when you will use it

People who decide the when in advance follow through more often than people who only intend to. Pick the moment in your week where the cue is most likely to show up.

…I will ask myself the three questions. Other whens: I avoid a certain hallway. A name makes me tense. I replay a meeting on the way home.

Saved in this browser only.

The daily rep

Once a day, notice one piece of unfinished business and ask yourself the three questions. At least once this month, make a real move toward repair.

The cue: You feel slightly different with someone and can trace it to a specific moment that was never addressed.

One line on the practice log each day you run it. A missed day is information.

Monthly Practice Log (PDF)

Attach it to a meeting you already hold

Use five minutes to ask: is there any unfinished repair business from the past quarter that we should name before moving on? Do not force it. Just open the space.

Each week: one prompt, then two from memory

Think of a time when you were harmed by something a colleague did or said. What would genuine repair have looked like? Did it happen?

Think of a time when you caused harm, even unintentionally. Did you repair it? If not, what got in the way?

Two from memory. Answer first, then check.

The three restorative questions.

What happened? What was the impact? What would make it right?

From Month 4: the four stages of the escalation arc.

Anxiety. Defensiveness. Acting out. Tension reduction.

What is the difference between an apology and repair in your experience? When have you offered or received one that felt complete?

Two from memory. Answer first, then check.

What does a transactional apology skip?

The person affected saying what it cost, and the other person understanding it.

From Month 2: the cue for the 30-Second Start.

You are certain about what someone meant, or why they did something.

Apply the 5 Whys to a piece of unfinished repair business: why has it not been addressed? And why that? Keep going.

Two from memory. Answer first, then check.

The one rule of the talking piece.

Only the person holding it speaks.

From Month 1: which beat of STOP do people skip?

Observe.

More to try between sessions, and the team artifact
  • Identify one piece of unfinished repair business, something unresolved with a colleague, and make one move toward it this month. An acknowledgment, a check-in, or simply naming that something needs attention all count. The full repair conversation can come later.
  • In your next significant mistake, try the restorative formula aloud: what happened, what was the impact on others, and what will I do differently. Say all three parts.

Team artifact this month: a repair protocol. Write it together before Month 6. One page.

  • Our team agrees that when something goes wrong, the first thing we do is:
  • Acknowledgment on this team looks like:
  • We consider repair complete when:
  • When neither person is ready to talk yet, we will:
  • Signed:
Questions for a mid-month check-in

Optional. Forty-five minutes, in pairs or small groups.

  • What did the circle practice surface that does not usually get said? Why does it not usually get said?
  • What is the difference between “I’m sorry you felt that way” and a genuine acknowledgment of harm? Have you been on either end?
  • Zehr argues the key questions are about needs and obligations, not blame. What would change in how your team handles mistakes if you used those questions instead?
  • Is there unfinished repair business on this team right now? What would it take to name it?

Three checks before you move on

  • Did I make at least one move toward a piece of unfinished repair business this month?
  • Did I use the restorative formula at least once?
  • Can I distinguish between an apology and genuine repair?
Next: Go deeper

Optional · for the weeks you have appetite

Go deeper

None of this is required. The rep is the practice. The media is the seasoning.

If you pick three

The rest of the list (5 more)
  1. WATCH Shannon Sliva: How Restorative Justice Could End Mass Incarceration The core principles and why they apply far beyond criminal contexts.
  2. WATCH Dan Reisel: The Neuroscience of Restorative Justice TED Talk.
  3. ARTICLE The Radical Work of Healing: Fania and Angela Davis on a New Kind of Civil Rights Activism (YES! Magazine) Fania Davis on moving from civil rights law to restorative practice, and the Indigenous and African roots of restorative justice that Zehr drew from.
  4. Book The Little Book of Restorative Justice (Howard Zehr)
  5. BOOK SUMMARY The Little Book of Circle Processes (Kay Pranis), summarized by Beyond Intractability (Kay Pranis)
Where this month’s ideas come from
From the fieldRESTORATIVE JUSTICE (HOWARD ZEHR)
Restorative justice emerged from Indigenous circle practices and was formally developed as a criminal justice alternative by practitioners like Zehr. Its core principle: harm creates obligations. Genuine repair requires three things most organizational apologies skip: acknowledgment of the specific harm, space for the affected person to describe the full impact, and a genuine plan for making it right.
From the fieldCIRCLE PROCESS (TAGISH AND TLINGIT TEACHERS, HOLLOW WATER FIRST NATION, KAY PRANIS)
The circle process most organizations meet today was carried into restorative practice by specific people: Harold and Phil Gatensby and Mark Wedge of the Carcross-Tagish and Dahka T’lingit First Nations in Yukon, and the community of Hollow Water First Nation in Manitoba. Kay Pranis, who served as restorative justice planner for the Minnesota Department of Corrections, learned from them and wrote the version many teams now use. Everyone has equal voice, one person speaks at a time, and the aim is understanding. Pranis describes it as a process that positions people to bring their best selves to their most difficult conversations. If you use it, say where it came from.
From the fieldBRAIDING SWEETGRASS (ROBIN WALL KIMMERER)
Kimmerer’s work on reciprocity, drawn from Potawatomi and other Indigenous traditions, offers a frame many organizational cultures lack: relationship is maintained through ongoing acts of acknowledgment and care, not just through the absence of conflict. Repair, in this frame, is part of how a healthy community sustains itself.
From the fieldTESHUVAH (JEWISH REPAIR TRADITION)
Teshuvah treats repair as a sequence rather than a sentiment. Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg, drawing on Maimonides, lays out five steps: name and own the harm, begin to change, make restitution and accept consequences, apologize, and make different choices when the situation recurs. The order matters. The apology comes fourth, after the work, which is the same distinction this month draws between an apology and repair.
From the fieldHOʻOPONOPONO (HAWAIIAN RECONCILIATION PRACTICE)
Hoʻoponopono, “to set right,” is a facilitated family practice for untangling harm. Native Hawaiian scholar Manu Meyer describes its phases: a respected facilitator (haku) opens with prayer, the problem is stated, the tangle is discussed layer by layer (mahiki), forgiveness is asked for and given (mihi), and the matter is released (kala). Its insight for teams is that repair has a defined ending. Once the process completes, the harm is no longer carried forward. (The four-phrase mantra sold under the same name is a later commercial adaptation and a different thing.)

For whoever runs the session

Running the session?

Facilitator guide

The circle requires careful setup. Set the container explicitly: what is said in the circle stays in the circle, no one is required to share what they are not ready to, the goal is understanding rather than resolution. Use an anonymized situation, not a live one. Give each of the three questions its own round before moving on. After the circle, ask what surprised people. Debrief the experience of the process, not the content.

Watch for people who skip to solutions before the impact is heard (return to the second question), people who minimize their own harm (“it was not a big deal” often means “I have carried it for months”), and emotion that surfaces unexpectedly (slow down, use STOP, do not rush past it).

Month 5 sometimes surfaces things that need more than this curriculum can hold. Have a plan for what you will do if that happens. Know in advance who you would call. If a client flags the co-billed Davis conversation in the media list, substitute Fania Davis's book The Little Book of Race and Restorative Justice; the Oakland classrooms article in this month covers the same ground.