Month 2 of 8
The Voice in Your Head
Facts, stories, the lint you have been carrying, and how to tell the difference.
The move
The 30-Second Start
The moment it is for
You find yourself certain about what someone meant, why they did something, or what it says about them.
What it takes
One 90-minute session. A minute or two a day. Ten minutes a week.
Start here · about 5 minutes
Guess, then read
This month's lens comes from the self-inquiry practices of organizational learning and mediation.
Two guesses before you read anything. Guessing first, even wrong, makes the reading stick. (It is also slightly annoying. Sorry.)
About that one-word reply
You send a careful, three-paragraph email. The reply comes back: “Fine.”
By the second read you know exactly what it means. She is annoyed. She thinks the idea is weak. She has never respected your work. (That escalated quickly.)
One word arrived. You built the rest yourself, in about two seconds, and it felt like reading.
Chris Argyris called the route you just took the ladder of inference.
The ladder, climbed in about two seconds
- 1FactWhat a camera would record.
- 2NoticeThe part I happened to see.
- 3StoryWhat I decided it means.
- 4ActWhat I do about it.
A fact is what a camera would record. A story is what you concluded. Most of what teams carry about each other is story, some of it years old and never checked.
Some stories are accurate. People who have spent years reading rooms shaped by power, role, and identity are often reading them correctly. So this month’s move keeps the story and checks it, with the one person who knows.
The 30-Second Start
- 1“I noticed…”What a camera would record. Nothing else.
- 2“The story I’m telling myself is…”Your interpretation, labeled as yours.
- 3“Is that accurate?”Then stop talking.
Start with a low-stakes one. The colleague who didn’t say good morning will do.
For a story with real charge: the 5 Whys
When you identify a story you’re carrying about a colleague or situation, ask why you believe it. Then ask why that’s the reason. Keep going, as many as five iterations. You will often find that the original story is resting on an assumption several layers down that has never been tested. Sometimes that assumption is accurate. Sometimes it dissolved years ago. In that case, consider cleaning the lint filter.
What are you so worried about?
What is the worst that could actually happen?
And what is it costing you to carry that worry right now?
These are not comfortable questions. Stay with them anyway.
Before the live session · one required piece
The Ladder of Inference (The Systems Thinker)
A short read on the full ladder.
On your own · about 12 minutes
Try it here
Three short practice rounds load here. If you are logged in to Squarespace and see only this line, view the page logged out.
The live session · 90 minutes
Practice together
One session at the start of the month. Everyone tries the move once, with real people.
Run the rep exactly as written. Replace the live session with a 45-minute solo session using the Facts vs. Stories worksheet on a real current tension. For external feedback, test one 30-Second Start on an actual person and notice their response.
What to have in the room
This month’s worksheet (PDF)Handouts and frameworks
A fact is what a camera would capture: observable behavior, specific words, documented events. A story is what you have concluded: what it means, why they did it, what it says about them.
FACT: “She did not speak during the last three meetings on this topic.”
STORY: '”She doesn't care.” / “She's passively withdrawing.” / “She's checked out.”
The story may be accurate. It may also be completely wrong. Most conflict conversations happen at the story level while both parties believe they are talking about facts.
How we move from raw data to action, usually in seconds, without realizing it.
- Observable data (what a camera would record)
- Selected data (what I noticed, already filtered by my existing beliefs)
- Interpretation (what I decide it means)
- Assumption (what I take for granted as true)
- Conclusion (what I now believe)
- Belief (which then shapes what data I select next, a self-reinforcing loop)
- Action (what I do as a result)
The climb from rung 1 to rung 7 happens invisibly. Slowing it down is the practice.
A template for externalizing a story before it runs the conversation:
“I noticed [specific observable behavior].”
“The story I am telling myself is [your interpretation].”
“I want to check that out. Is that accurate?”
Example: “I noticed you went quiet when we discussed the budget. The story I am telling myself is that you disagree but didn't feel safe to say so. Is that accurate?”
What makes this work: you name your story as a story, not a fact.
Three practice scenarios
Scenario 1
A usually active colleague has been quiet for two weeks. Write your story about why. Now write the observable facts. What data are you selecting? What would you say using the 30-Second Start?
Scenario 2
Someone replies to a thoughtful email with two terse sentences. You feel dismissed. What is the fact? What are three plausible stories? Which one are you treating as true, and why?
Scenario 3
Apply the 5 Whys to a story you are currently carrying about a colleague: why do you believe it? Why that? Keep going. What do you find at the bottom?
All month · a minute or two a day
Keep it going
Decide now when you will use it
People who decide the when in advance follow through more often than people who only intend to. Pick the moment in your week where the cue is most likely to show up.
…I will check my story before I act on it. Other whens: a short email from a certain person. I’m composing a pointed reply. I hear myself say “they always.”
Saved in this browser only.
The daily rep
Once a day, when you catch yourself certain about what someone meant, say the story out loud as a story, and check it.
The cue: You find yourself certain about what someone meant, why they did something, or what it says about them.
One line on the practice log each day you run it. A missed day is information.
Monthly Practice Log (PDF)Attach it to a meeting you already hold
Use the lint filter question before a recurring agenda item: “Before we get into this, is there anything from our last conversation that didn’t land right and we never addressed?” Give it 60 seconds.
Each week: one prompt, then two from memory
Identify a current tension you are holding. Write two columns: FACTS (what a camera would capture) and STORIES (what you have concluded). Count the items in each column.
Choose the story with the most emotional charge. Apply the 5 Whys: why do you believe it? And why that? Keep going. What do you find at the bottom?
Two from memory. Answer first, then check.
The three lines of the 30-Second Start.
“I noticed [what a camera would record]. The story I’m telling myself is [my interpretation]. Is that accurate?”
From Month 1: the four beats of STOP.
Stop. Take a breath. Observe what is happening inside you. Proceed on purpose.
Use the 30-Second Start template once in a real conversation, or write out what you would have said if you had used it. What made it hard?
Two from memory. Answer first, then check.
What makes something a fact?
A camera and a microphone would have captured it.
From Month 1: name three of the five SCARF domains.
Status. Certainty. Autonomy. Relatedness. Fairness.
Lint filter: What have you been carrying about a colleague that you formed at least six months ago? Have circumstances changed? Have you tested the story recently?
Two from memory. Answer first, then check.
The three worry questions.
What am I worried about? What is the worst that could actually happen? What is it costing me to carry this?
From Month 1: you are activated and you have a story. Which move comes first?
STOP. Regulate first, then check the story.
More to try between sessions, and the team artifact
- Use the 30-Second Start template at least once in a real conversation. The goal is to externalize a story rather than present it as fact.
- Identify one thing you have been carrying about a person or situation that you have not examined in a while. Ask the three questions: what am I worried about? What is the worst that could actually happen? What is this costing me to carry?
Team artifact this month: a facts and stories reference card. Complete it together in the session or before Month 3. Three columns:
- Behaviors we have observed (facts)
- Stories we tend to tell
- Questions we could ask to test the story
Questions for a mid-month check-in
Optional. Forty-five minutes, in pairs or small groups.
- When you did the Facts vs. Stories exercise, what was the ratio? What surprised you about that ratio?
- Have you ever been on the receiving end of the fundamental attribution error? What was that like?
- What came up when you applied the 5 Whys to a story you are carrying? Did you get to the bottom of it?
- What would change in this team if we were more willing to externalize our stories rather than act on them as facts?
Three checks before you move on
- Did I use the 30-Second Start template at least once this month?
- Did I identify at least one piece of lint I have been carrying and examine whether it is still accurate?
- Did I ask the three worry questions honestly: what am I worried about, what is the worst that could happen, and what is this costing me?
Optional · for the weeks you have appetite
Go deeper
None of this is required. The rep is the practice. The media is the seasoning.
If you pick three
- ReadThe Fundamental Attribution Error (Harvard Business School Online) The bias behind most stories about colleagues: their behavior is character, ours is circumstance.
- TryTake the Implicit Association Test (Harvard Project Implicit) Ten minutes of watching your own automatic associations at work. Treat it as an experience. It diagnoses nobody.
- ListenFinding Our Way: Visioning with adrienne maree brown (hosted by Prentis Hemphill) adrienne maree brown and Prentis Hemphill on the stories we carry, and whether they still serve us.
The rest of the list (3 more)
- ARTICLE Decoding the Fundamental Attribution Error (Psychology Today) Practical strategies for catching yourself mid-attribution.
- ARTICLE Profile of Mahzarin Banaji (PNAS, the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences) Profile of Banaji's research by the National Academy of Sciences. Covers the IAT, implicit bias findings, and what 25 years of research tells us about changing minds.
- Book Blindspot: Hidden Biases of Good People (Banaji and Greenwald)
Where this month’s ideas come from
For whoever runs the session
Running the session?
Facilitator guide
The lint filter exercise is the emotional center of this month. Give it at least 20 minutes and do not rush past the discomfort when it surfaces. When people share their facts vs. stories split, follow up: what would you need to do to test that story? Keep it concrete. The 30-Second Start sounds formulaic. It is. Acknowledge that the language feels awkward and proceed anyway. Pair people with real working tension for the practice. It is harder and more useful.
Watch for highly abstract stories (ask for a specific recent example), people who resist the lint filter question (they may be carrying something significant; note it, do not push), and people who say everything is fine (ask: if you had to name one small piece of lint, what would it be?).
This is often the month where something real surfaces that had been buried. If that happens: slow down, use looping (you will formally introduce it next month), and thank the person for naming it.